Daily updates on the Internet and its social and public policy implications, useful websites, political/cultural musings and more from a UK-based academic (PhD researcher at Media@LSE), Internet consultant and journalist
31 May, 2002

Even if you use cryptography to secure your email (and almost nobody does anyway) you still may not be safe, as Lenny Foner pointed out on a mailing list recently:

Someone was saying that the forged email generated by that pesky Klez virus would encourage people to use digitally signed email (so you should be able to verify that the sender is really that email address instead of a forged email address). He responded:

Signed on the Windows box? Since these things are running on OS’s
that don’t have a security perimeter (otherwise, these worms wouldn’t
be running there in the first place, right?), then:
(a) Son of Klez grabs your passphrase, and then
(b) Forges -signed- mail from you

What better way to completely invalidate the whole -concept- of
trusting cryptographically-signed mail? The mere existence of
anything like this would certainly give lots of plausible deniability
to anyone trying to prove in court that they did -not- sign a message,
make some transaction, etc. In court now, a handwritten signature
doesn’t prove much, since forgers exist—it’s the testimony by the
signer or the witness that the signer signed something, or the
circumstances around it that lead to a preponderance of evidence one
way or the other (I’m assuming a civil proceeding here). But with
Son of Klez, there doesn’t even have to be a human forger in the loop.

Such things are already easy to write, of course. But someone arguing
that they didn’t sign something might have an uphill battle convincing
a jury that some evildoer had compromised their machine. If they
could point to a known worm that did this and had compromised a
million machines, they wouldn’t have to make the case that they were
some special target—merely that they ran with the herd and used the
same operating system everyone else did.

This is why, about a decade ago, I was arguing that the -right- way to
use things like PGP was in a special-purpose box that -only- ran PGP,
had a built-in keyboard and screen, and only talked to the rest of the
world via a serial connection that -only- passed cleartext and signed
or encrypted stuff. The idea was that you write the mail anywhere
(on the box or not), have -its screen- show you the contents, then
sign/encrypt there, in the secure environment, where people can’t
easily infect your machine with a keyboard sniffer, or have it change
what you -thought- you were signing just before it gets signed, etc.
Pilots didn’t (quite) exist, and are only now getting fast enough not
to be painful for certain private-key operations, so I didn’t pursue
it at the time. But it was obvious that running PGP on a general-purpose
machine was sheer folly, especially if it ran a popular and insecure OS.
(I’ve omitted many technical details here; for example, you wouldn’t
-really- want to run this on a Pilot unless you broke its ability to
sync, since every sync is a way to compromise the code it’s running.)

P.S. I can’t wait for the stealthy worm that grabs credit card
numbers which are entered in forms. Or makes phantom purchases
on Amazon, or phantom bids on eBay, or… All of these would be
tremendously disruptive, yet awfully easy to write…

No Comments

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Widget_logo

Media (Daily)
BBC News Online bookforum
(Weekly)
lifehacker - but I only look at their top these days. The Economist (I listen to the audio edition)
Arts & Letters Daily
The New Yorker & its cartoons

(Monthly or more infrequently)
Wired magazine
Prospect magazine (if you think The Economist is dumbed down)
Maisonneuve magazine
The Walrus
First Monday - an Internet-only peer reviewed journal of Internet studies
Gnovis - peer-reviewed journal of Communication, Culture and Technology
Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication
...and various other journals you can't access for free.

Virtual Communities I belong to
The Well
Brainstorms from Howard Rheingold
CIX the UK's "Well" for over 15 years
I'm also on Facebook

Comics
Doonesbury
Dilbert

Multimedia
US Public Radio
Day to Day NPR daily topical feature show inc. Slate content
BBC Radio 4 - archived for a week after broadcast
BBC Radio Drama original drama and serialised books
BBC7 radio dramas and comedy from BBC archives
The News Quiz

BBC World Service
Analysis
Assignment
Off the Shelf (serialised books)
Other non-podcast multimedia
The Daily Show biting American political satire.
Odd Todd periodically updated amusing Flash cartoons
Tales of Mere Existence excellent Quicktime animated short vignettes.
Guardian - monthly Cybercinema roundup
OneWord Radio audiobooks and author interviews

Podcasts

News/Current Affairs/Factual Thinking Allowed weekly interviews with academics
This American Life superb storytelling
LSE public lectures The University Channel guest lectures at major US universities
The Guardian's Podcasts
Slate's podcasts
From Our Own Correspondent

Fiction/drama
Escape Pod - SF short stories
Librivox - volunteer readers read classic fiction.
Craphound - Cory Doctorow reads his works
NPR book reviews

Digital Planet tech radio programme with emphasis on the developing world (now being podcast)
(also see the Go Digital special Digital Destinations) and Bill Thompson's thoughts about recent Digital Planets
IT Conversations: Blogging (broadcasts from conferences - other topics available)
NPR has a weekly tech roundup

Useful stuff
Various handy free/cheap Mac apps (updated regularly)
Online virus scanner
Free anti-virus software
Dave's Quick Search Toolbar Google taskbar on steroids
Workrave Free RSI prevention software
Powermarks Superb Windows bookmark manager ($25)
Netvouz This may be the most full-featured web bookmark manager around.
Endnote ($239 ) Great software for managing academic citations (or try one of these)
snipurl lets you share long urls easily
Mailwasher Lets you choose between several blacklists and other filtering tools to get rid of spam from multiple POP3 mailboxes - and it is free!
SpamMotel - Free disposable email addresses that let you see who is misusing the one you gave them
DigiGuide - a fast, powerful TV guide for your PC, covering the UK, US or Ireland
TotalRecorder - a powerful, inexpensive way to record streaming audio into MP3 files to take away.
QuestionPro survey software Lots of features and free for academic use.

What's the weather like here?

The WeatherPixie

Copyright

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
  • Meta:

  • Meta:
  • Generously hosted 2001 to Aug 2003 by Reid Ellis and from then until mid-2005 by Harald Koch. Thanks to both!
    Try Clarity Capital Partners for your strategic technology consulting and corporate finance needs.

    Blogger Code
    B9 d t k s u- f- i o- x- e l- c--